Mark Hatch-Miller

TRIAL AND ARBITRATION

• Moskowitz Family LLC v. Globus Medical Inc. (E.D. Penn.) Served as co-lead trial counsel for client Globus Medical Inc., and successfully defended the company against an $86 million patent infringement claim by a Maryland doctor and his family. Mark delivered Globus’s opening and put on its first witness. After an eight-day trial, a jury in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania found that not a single one of ten accused Globus products infringed a single one of Moskowitz’s three asserted patents. Read more.
• Flexuspine Inc. v. Globus Medical Inc. (E.D. Tex.) Won a take-nothing defense verdict for medical device manufacturer Globus Medical, in a patent infringement dispute before a Texas federal court. Mark also obtained several key pre-verdict wins in the case, including on summary judgment motions and motions to limit expert testimony. After the Globus trial win, Mark co-wrote an article for The Corporate Counselor about his experience trying the case.
• Westlake Chemical v. James Construction et al. (334th District Court of Harris County, Texas) Won a more than $4 million breach of contract trial verdict for Westlake Chemical against James Construction Group in Texas state court. The jury sided with Westlake on claims that safety issues justified removing the contractor, James, from a $400 million construction project. The result was later modified by the Texas Supreme Court.
• Intrepid Investments v. Selling Source (New York Supreme Court, Commercial Division) Represented online advertising firm Selling Source in a New York arbitration regarding the equity earn-out provision in an acquisition contract and won an award rejecting 93% of the plaintiff’s claims, and ordering the plaintiff to reimburse arbitrator fees previously paid by Selling Source.

PRE-TRIAL

• YH Lex Estates v. HFZ Capital Group (New York Supreme Court, Commercial Division) Won summary judgment for plaintiff YH Lex Estates against a guarantor defendant in a New York state court action seeking to collect a nearly $20 million debt, and later won summary judgment for the same plaintiff on its separate $12.6 million voidable transfer claims against two transferee defendants.
• Intrepid Investments, LLC v. Speedwell Holdings (New York Supreme Court, Commercial Division) Obtained a complete defense-side summary judgment win for online advertising firm Speedwell Holdings (formerly known as Selling Source), in a New York state court breach of contract dispute over an alleged $28.7 million debt.
• In re Sensata Technologies (New York Supreme Court, Nassau County Branch) Won a complete defense-side summary judgment victory for auto parts manufacturer Sensata Technologies, in a New York state court product liability case.

APPELLATE

• Intrepid Investments, LLC v. Selling Source, LLC (New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department) Secured a major appellate win for client Speedwell Holdings (formerly known as Selling Source) in New York State Court. The order affirmed a prior no-liability summary judgment ruling by the New York Supreme Court’s Commercial Division in a complex $28.7 million commercial loan case, brought by plaintiff Intrepid Investments.
• YH Lex Estates, LLC v. Nir Meir et al (New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department) Won an appeal affirming a nearly $14 million fraudulent transfer judgement on behalf of client YH Lex Estates, LLC.
• YH Lex Estates v. HFZ Capital Group (New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department) In a New York state court action seeking to collect a nearly $20 million debt for plaintiff YH Lex Estates, won a unanimous summary judgment ruling on appeal against a real estate firm defendant and its founder. You can watch Mark argue the appellate case here (start @23:19).

LANDMARK SETTLEMENTS

• Dominion Inc. et al. v. Fox News Network LLC (Delaware Sup. Ct.). Helped secure a historic $787.5 million deal for Dominion Voting Systems to resolve a $1.6 billion lawsuit it brought against Fox News and Fox Corporation over claims that Fox News and its commentators relentlessly stated that Dominion’s voting machines were at the center of a vast conspiracy in the 2020 presidential election.
• United States of America ex rel. Gauch v. Lincare Holdings Inc. (S.D.N.Y.) Secured a deal valued at $25.5 million to resolve a False Claims Act lawsuit based on allegations of fraud and kickbacks made by Susman Godfrey clients, and former Lincare employees, Sandra Gauch and Michelle McNeill. Lincare agreed to the settlement to resolve the whistleblowers’ allegations that it submitted false claims to federal health programs.
• United States of America et al. ex rel. Martinez et al., v. Apria Healthcare Group, Inc., and Apria Healthcare LLC (S.D.N.Y.) Represented whistleblowers and helped the government secure a  $40.5 million settlement in a medical false claims lawsuit in New York Federal Court against Apria Healthcare Group; the whistleblowers recovered $4.34 million.
• In re: NYC Bus Tour Antitrust Litigation (S.D.N.Y.) Secured a $19 million settlement(approximately $12 million after fees and expenses) for the class in a New York federal court price-fixing case against Coach USA Inc. and City Sights LLC, providers of “hop-on, hop-off” double-decker bus tours of New York City.
• AIG Securities Fraud Litigation (S.D.N.Y.). Represented Pacific Life Funds and OppenheimerFunds as opt-outs from the landmark New York federal court securities fraud class action against American International Group, arising from AIG’s misstatements and omissions to investors leading up to its 2008 bailout; the cases settled on confidential terms.
• In re Payment Card Interchange Fee and Merchant Discount Antitrust Litigation (E.D.N.Y.) Represented Walmart in contract and antitrust lawsuits in New York state and federal court against Visa USA; the cases settled on confidential terms.
• In re General Motors Ignition Switch Litigation (S.D.N.Y.) Represented plaintiffs in a federal multi-district litigation against General Motors over an ignition switch defect. Mark’s work on a key personal injury bellwether case in New York federal court contributed to a favorable settlement on the eve of trial. This case received substantial press from outlets such as The Wall Street Journal.

• US Dominion Inc. et al. v. Fox News Network LLC (Superior Court of the State of Delaware) Serving as counsel to Dominion Voting Machines in its defamation lawsuits against Newsmax TV, OAN and several other high profile defendants. Dominion accuses the defendants of making false claims that Dominion rigged the 2020 Presidential Election.
• Langer v. CME Group, Inc. (Circuit Court Of Cook County, Illinois County Department, Chancery Division) Serving as counsel for individual plaintiffs and a proposed class of members of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange and the Chicago Board of Trade. The case alleges that CME and CBOT breached their most fundamental obligations to members under the exchanges’ respective corporate charters, including by opening an electronic trading floor without required member approval.  Additional information about the case is available here.
• Globus Medical v. Life Spine (D. Delaware) Representing Globus Medical in a plaintiff-side patent infringement case against competitor Life Spine, related to Globus’s innovative expandable spinal fusion implant technologies.
• BML Properties Ltd. v. China Construction America (New York Supreme Court, Commercial Division) Counsel to BML Properties on claims that China Construction America, one of the largest contractors in the world, and other defendants committed fraud in connection with BMLP’s development of the “Baha Mar” resort complex in the Bahamas.
• Macquarie Energy Winter Storm Litigation (Various). Representing Macquarie Energy in multiple disputes arising from the February 2021 winter storm Uri in Texas.
• NASDAQ, Inc. v. Miami International Holdings (D.N.J.) Representing NASDAQ in a trade secrets misappropriation litigation against competitor MIAX, and defending NASDAQ against antitrust and other counterclaims.